Please zoom in or out and select the base layer according to your preference to make the map ready for printing, then press the Print button above.

“Franken” shipwreck from WWII threatens Baltic Sea near Gdańsk, Poland


Description:

On the 8th of April of 1945, during WWII, the German tanker "Franken" was hit by torpedoes of the Soviet airforce and sunk in the Baltic Sea near the Polish bay.[1, 6] The ships original purpose was to be used as a “floating gas station” providing gas and oil for other ships being used in the war. The tanks contain 11 810t of liquid oil and oils or 1.5 million liters of fuel. Due to corrosion, the walls of the tank get thinner every year. The walls containing the fuel was originals 12mm thick. Every decade that passes the walls get thinner by 1mm. 77 years have passed since the ship sunk. At any point the tank could collapse under its own weight, releasing tons of hazardous chemicals into the waters of the Baltic Sea.[2] Leakage is going to have fatal effects on the environment. This would be threatening living organisms in the water, killing them or disturb them in their natural habitat. The Polish citizens living in proximity would also be affected negatively. Their access to water and seafood or fish from the Baltic Sea would be limited, tourism would be affected negatively due to visual impacts of the release of the fuels in the water, impacting the economy.

Furthermore, the toxic and carcinogenic substances could cause health problems in the future for the population living nearby.[3] The shipwreck is currently property of the Polish government. A preliminary action plan for retrieval activities for "Franken" has been drafted, but no action has been taken yet.[4]

The main objective is to salvage the fuel and then dispose it which is a very costly venture. According to Benedykt Hac, Oceanography Department of the Maritime Institute in Gdansk, costs of €8-20 million can be estimated.[5]

The MARE foundation, founded in 2016, is the only non-governmental organization in Poland focused on the protection of the Baltic ecosystem, gathering 45.000 signatures on demand of the Polish government to clean the tanks. They goal is to raise public awareness and plan activities to solve these issues. Among those activities there is a ready-made wreck management

program for Poland they published in 2021, “General Methodology of Oil Removal Operations on Baltic Shipwrecks” [7], to deal with shipwrecks in the Baltic Sea in general and the “Preliminary Action Plan for the retrieval activities on the Franken shipwreck”[4] for this specific shipwreck. This is based on underwater investigations and documentations of the shipwreck carried out by the German “Baltic Sea Conservation Foundation (“Baltcf”) on the 23rd – 26th of April 2018.[4]

Basic Data

Name of conflict:“Franken” shipwreck from WWII threatens Baltic Sea near Gdańsk, Poland
Country:Poland
Location of conflict:Baltic Sea near Gdańsk, Poland
Accuracy of locationMEDIUM (Regional level)

Source of Conflict

Type of conflict. 1st level:Infrastructure and Built Environment
Type of conflict. 2nd level:Pollution related to transport (spills, dust, emissions)
Specific commodities:Crude oil

Project Details and Actors

Project details

A preliminary research expedition by the MARE foundation, Baltcf and Maritime Institute in Gdańsk was carried out on 23rd-28th of April 2018 [4].

It was estimated that approx. 1.5 milion liters of fuel is still inside of the tanker [4]. However, the exact current loading is unknown. It was impossible to determine which tanks contain oil but it was possible to determine which don't because of the unsealing. Tanks that look sealed could contain 4,608 tonnes of different types of oil. Almost half of the volume of the tanks is still sealed, without any access from the outside, which means that each of the 5 sealed tanks can be filled with oil.

The sealed tanks have a capacity between 573 tonnes to 1221 tonnes [4]. The cost of operation to extract the fuel was estimated for around 8-20 million EUR [4]. There is no estimation of the population that is going to be affected however, Tricity (Gdansk, Gdynia, Sopot) population itself is about 1.5 milion. The values of polyaromatic hydrocarbons (PAH) in the samples collected in the close vicinity of the wreck (near field) dramatically exceed the limit values imposed by the environmental regulator [4].

Level of Investment for the conflictive project21,709,600
Type of populationUnknown
Affected Population:1.5 milion <
Start of the conflict:01/06/2018
Relevant government actors:- Instytut Morski w Gdańsku (Maritime Institute in Gdansk)
- Polish Ministry of Maritime Economy and Inland Navigation
Environmental justice organizations (and other supporters) and their websites, if available:- MARE foundation
https://fundacjamare.pl/en/shipwrecks/
- Baltic Sea Conservation Foundation
https://baltcf.org/

Conflict & Mobilization

IntensityLOW (some local organising)
Reaction stageIn REACTION to the implementation (during construction or operation)
Groups mobilizing:Local ejos
Neighbours/citizens/communities
Forms of mobilization:Community-based participative research (popular epidemiology studies, etc..)
Development of alternative proposals
Involvement of national and international NGOs
Official complaint letters and petitions
Public campaigns

Impacts

Environmental ImpactsPotential: Biodiversity loss (wildlife, agro-diversity), Oil spills, Surface water pollution / Decreasing water (physico-chemical, biological) quality
Health ImpactsPotential: Exposure to unknown or uncertain complex risks (radiation, etc…)
Socio-economical ImpactsPotential: Lack of work security, labour absenteeism, firings, unemployment, Loss of livelihood

Outcome

Project StatusIn operation
Conflict outcome / response:Strengthening of participation
Under negotiation
New Environmental Impact Assessment/Study
Proposal and development of alternatives:The MARE Foundation, together with The Maritime Institute in Gdansk, made the "Preliminary action plan for the retrieval activitties on the Franken shipwreck", first published in 2018 [4].

In it, we can see different explanations of the development of alternatives in order to clean the shipwreck before it becomes a worse environmental issue. There were 3 different clean-up methods chosen:
1. Backfilling the wreck.
2. Pumping oil from the wreck with diving systems and hot-tapping system.
3. Pumping oil form the wreck but, instead, using remote control systems and hot-tapping as well.

One of the advantages of the first option mentioned is that it may be effective, considering the objectives of such a project, but on the bad side, it can pullute the water during the execution of this method.

The second option, sounds more convenient since it won't produce any leacks, so it would be better for the enviroment. Despite this, it has their own limitations, even though the technology used is very modern and the draining would be carried out with no problems, it is not adapted to solve these type of issues which are found more than 100 metres depth. Therefore, the only way to go further, is by using remote control systems instead. That is why, the third method would be the most adecuate for the situation of the shipwreck back in 2018.
Do you consider this an environmental justice success? Was environmental justice served?:No
Briefly explain:At the moment, this conflict is not yet solved so, as for now, we cannot really tell if it is a success or not. What we can say is that, currently, there are no actions being made, so, if we had to give an answer, this environmental issue is not a success since it is not being resovoled by the Polish nor German government.

Sources & Materials

[1] Alexandra, P. 06/04/2018. Eco-bomb ticking: WWII shipwreck threatens Baltic Sea. In The First News.
https://www.thefirstnews.com/article/eco-bomb-ticking-wwii-shipwreck-threatens-baltic-sea-1015

[2] Baltcf website. Reduction of negative impact of oil spills from the Franken shipwreck. Visited on 16/02/2023
https://baltcf.org/project/reduction-of-the-negative-impact-of-oil-spills-from-the-franken-shipwreck/

[3] Bielatowicz, A. 20/06/2018. Save the Baltic Sea. In Vimeo.
https://vimeo.com/276085670

[4] Fundacja Mare, Instytut Morski w Gdańsku (MIG). 2022. Preliminary Action Plan for the retrieval activities on the Franken shipwreck.

ON THE FRANKEN SHIPWRECK
https://fundacjamare.pl/file/repository/MARE_report_EN_FRANKEN_1_.pdf

[5] Rycicka, A. 24/09/2018. German WWII wreck in Poland an eco-threat. In DW.
https://www.dw.com/en/german-wwii-wreck-poses-threat-of-eco-disaster-in-poland/a-45621533

[6] Hoare, C. 15/05/2020. World War 2: Why experts fear Baltic Sea shipwreck is 'ticking time-bomb'. In Express.
https://www.express.co.uk/news/world/1282866/world-war-2-baltic-sea-franken-tanker-nazi-germany-timebomb-environment-warning-spt

[7] Fundacja Mare. 2022. General Methodology of Oil Removal Operations on Baltic Shipwrecks.
https://fundacjamare.pl/file/repository/2021MARE_WRECKS_GENERAL_METHODOLOGY_of_oil_removal_operations_REPORT.pdf

Related media links to videos, campaigns, social network

Fundacja Mare. Stop the Spillage, sign the petition.
https://ratujbaltyk.fundacjamare.pl/en/

Meta information

Contributor:Albane Ballu, Elizaveta Filina, Klaudia Czajka, Ceyda Paksoy, Maria Isabel Brau Soto, Urszula Poleszuk
Last update29/12/2022
Conflict ID:6247

Images

 

The Franken ship during the attack, 8th April 1945, during sinking, visible damage to the bow just before breaking

 

The Franken ship during the attack, 8th April 1945, the explosion of ammunition storage and oil tanks (

 

The distribution of the depth around the Franken wreck, visualisation of data obtained by MBES

 

The deck in the area of the sterncastle, on starboard

 

Position of the Franken shipwreck in the Gdańsk Bay

[8] Fundacja Mare. 2021. General Methodology of Oil Removal Operations on Baltic Shipwrecks.